avery

How Avery Decides Which LinkedIn Profile Fix You Do First

Any competent reviewer can find fifteen problems with a LinkedIn profile. That part is not hard, and it is not where the value is. The value is in knowing which two of those fifteen actually change what happens to you, and in what order to do them.

This is a methodology post about how Avery orders the fixes it recommends. It is not built on customer data, and there are no statistics in it, because I am not going to invent any. It is built on the scoring logic itself, which is deterministic and can be described honestly.

Every fix Avery surfaces gets sorted against three things: how much score it moves, how long it takes, and what it unblocks. Those three interact in ways that are not obvious, and the interactions are the interesting part.

The problem with a flat list

Most audit tools output a checklist. Add a banner. Write a longer About section. Get more endorsements. Post weekly. Fill your skills. Every item is presented at the same weight, which quietly implies they matter equally.

They do not, and the gap is enormous. On Avery's weighting, First Impression carries 35 percent of a job-search score and Visibility carries 10. A flat checklist that puts "add a background image" next to "your headline does not say what you do" is not neutral. It is actively misleading, because it lets someone spend their Saturday on the 10 percent while the 35 percent sits untouched. The reasoning behind those weights is in why First Impression is 35 percent of your score.

Worse, a flat list encourages completeness as the goal. Completeness is a bad goal for a LinkedIn profile. A fully populated profile that says nothing specific performs worse than a half-populated one with a precise headline and two real proof points.

The three inputs

Score impact

This is mechanical. Every finding maps to a component, every component sits inside a pillar, and every pillar has a weight that shifts with the goal you selected. A headline problem on a job-search profile is worth several times what the same problem is worth on a thought-leadership profile, because the pillar weights differ by mode. Two people with identical profiles get different fix orders if their goals differ, which is the whole point of scoring by goal rather than against a universal ideal. That mechanic is explained in why the same profile scores differently by goal.

Effort

Estimated honestly, in minutes, and it varies far more than people expect. Rewriting a headline is fifteen minutes. Rewriting an About section that actually says something is closer to ninety, because the hard part is not writing, it is deciding what you are claiming. Building a genuine Featured section can take days, because it may require producing the artifact you are going to feature.

Effort matters for a reason that is behavioral rather than mathematical. Someone who does two fixes and sees movement continues. Someone who opens a ninety-minute task first, stalls, and closes the tab does zero fixes. Ordering that ignores effort produces plans that do not get executed, and a plan that does not get executed has a score impact of zero regardless of how correct it was.

Dependency

This is the input that most audit tools have no concept of, and it changes everything.

LinkedIn profile sections are not independent. They inherit language from each other, top down. Your headline sets the vocabulary. Your About section elaborates the headline's claim. Your experience bullets supply the evidence for the About section's claim. Your skills reflect the language used above them.

Which means if you rewrite the About section before the headline, and then fix the headline afterward, you have to rewrite the About section again, because it now elaborates a claim you no longer make. The work does not add, it repeats.

So dependency imposes a hard ordering constraint that overrides both score impact and effort:

Headline, then About, then Experience, then Skills, then Featured, then activity.

Within each stage you can order by impact and effort freely. Across stages, you do not skip ahead. A high-impact Experience fix waits behind a lower-impact headline fix, because doing them out of order means doing the Experience fix twice.

Leverage over completeness

The principle that falls out of all three inputs: fix what changes the read, not what fills the field.

A concrete version of the distinction. Two findings on the same profile.

Finding A: Skills section has 14 of 50 slots used.

Finding B: Headline reads "Experienced Professional | Results-Driven Leader | Open to Opportunities."

A checklist mindset says A is a bigger gap, because 36 empty slots is a larger number than one bad sentence. The scoring says B, decisively. A recruiter reading finding B's headline learns nothing about what you do, which means the eight seconds they spend on your profile produce no reason to keep reading. The empty skill slots cost you some search surface. The empty headline costs you the entire read.

This is also why "add more" recommendations rank low in general. More skills, more connections, more posts. They increase surface without increasing specificity, and specificity is what converts. The exception is proof, where more genuinely is better, because each additional concrete piece of evidence independently raises credibility. That distinction is covered in how the Proof pillar is scored.

Two rules that override the ordering

Two categories jump the queue regardless of what the arithmetic says.

Contradictions come first. If your headline says one thing and your most recent experience entry says something incompatible, that is not a low score on two components. It is a credibility problem that damages everything around it. A profile claiming a pivot into product while every entry describes operations work does not read as a pivot, it reads as confusion, and the reader stops trusting the rest of the page. Contradictions get fixed before anything gets optimized.

Blockers come before improvements. If your profile is set to private in recruiter search, no amount of headline work matters, because the audience cannot arrive. Same for a broken custom URL, an unreachable contact method, or a Featured link that 404s. These are usually five-minute fixes with low direct score impact and enormous practical impact, because they are gates rather than gradients. Anything that prevents arrival is worth more than anything that improves the experience after arrival.

Why three, not fifteen

Avery surfaces roughly nine findings and puts a small number of them in priority position. That is a deliberate constraint, not a limitation.

Fifteen prioritized items is not a priority list, it is the same flat checklist with numbers on it. The point of prioritizing is to make the rest wait. If someone does three fixes well, the profile has meaningfully changed. If they attempt fifteen, they typically do the six easiest, which by construction are the ones that matter least, because easy and low-impact correlate heavily on LinkedIn.

There is a second reason. After the first three fixes land, the profile is different, and the next-best action may have changed. A headline rewrite can resolve a Story pillar finding without touching the Story section, because the About section's ambiguity was inherited from the headline. Re-evaluating after a small batch produces a better second batch than committing to a long list up front.

Run this on your own profile

The methodology works without the tool. Open your profile and do this in order.

1. Check the gates. Are you visible in recruiter search? Does your custom URL work? Does every Featured link load? Is there a way to contact you? Fix anything broken before you evaluate anything else. Ten minutes.

2. Look for contradictions. Read your headline, then your About first paragraph, then your most recent role title. Do those three make one claim or three claims? If three, that is your first real fix.

3. Apply the eight-second test to your headline. Show it to someone outside your field and ask what you do and who you would be useful to. If they cannot answer both, the headline is the fix, and nothing below it should be touched yet.

4. Work down, never up. Headline, About, Experience, Skills, Featured, activity. Finish a stage before starting the next one.

5. Stop at three and reread the whole profile. Top to bottom, as a stranger. The fourth fix you would have picked before the first three is often not the fourth fix you need after them.

The honest limitation

Prioritization is a model, and models are wrong in specific ways worth naming.

Score impact is measurable, so it gets weighted heavily. Some things that matter are not measurable. Whether your About section sounds like a person rather than a template is a real factor in whether someone reaches out, and it resists scoring. Avery evaluates it, but any scoring system will systematically underweight what it cannot cleanly quantify, and the honest thing is to say so rather than pretend the number captures everything. Related: how to make your LinkedIn not sound AI-written.

The other limitation is that a profile is not a strategy. A perfectly ordered set of fixes produces a profile that converts the attention it gets. It does not produce the attention. If nobody is looking, sequence does not matter, and the work belongs somewhere else entirely.

Want the ordered version for your specific profile and goal? Run an Avery audit. You get the score across all four pillars, the findings behind it, and the fixes in the order that makes each one count.

Ready to put this into action?

Get a personalized LinkedIn audit from Avery — built on 12,000+ real coaching sessions.

Get My Audit